Perusing West Indies Keepers......the Best Man Shud Always be Pik

Perusing West Indies Keepers......the Best Man Shud Always be Pik

mapoui
Topic Author
Visitor

13 Sep 2017 13:03 #350818 by mapoui

I am trying to figure out the best batting west indian keepers in order of class.....

looking at Ramdin and Dowrich today and the circumstances this interest came to mind..the best ever

the best batting keepers to my mind are :
1] Walcott
2] Dujon
3] Desmond Lewis

next..a bunch hard to separate

Ramdin
Jacobs
David Murray
Gerry Alexander
Ivor Mendonza

now Ramdn has scored 4-5 tons..more than Alexander and Jacobs who had 1 each. I don't think David Murray had any. but all these guys were strong batsmen who scored more often than not

then there was another bunch that cud also score led by
Jackie Hendriks
Deryck Murray
Derek Sealy
David Allan
Cyril Christiani
Ivan Barrow
Clairmonte Deeiaza

then there were the Brilliant keepers
Jackie Hendriks
Gerry Alexander
Simpson Guillen
David Murray
Dujon
Ramdin
Jacobs

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_West_Indies_Test_wicket-keepers

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

ketchim
Offline
Platinum Member

13 Sep 2017 13:47 #350822 by ketchim

You know I realised tha Art of Scouts

is not in the west indian set up any longer!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

mapoui
Topic Author
Visitor

13 Sep 2017 13:56 #350823 by mapoui

I am interested in the best team playing at all times..the best players.

it is a jackass thing, a self defeating thing... for Ramdin to be sitting while Dowrich is dropping catches behind the stumps and scoring nothing in front of them while west indies loose

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

ketchim
Offline
Platinum Member

13 Sep 2017 14:29 #350829 by ketchim

and big men proposing a newbie Hamilton :

unbelieveable ! just cannot fathom that

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

ketchim
Offline
Platinum Member

13 Sep 2017 15:29 #350834 by ketchim

how come you nah mention Ivan Madray ... :-\

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Googley
Visitor

13 Sep 2017 15:49 #350840 by Googley

Milton Pydana was overlooked despite being good. Deryck Murray was the chosen one during that period.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

ketchim
Offline
Platinum Member

13 Sep 2017 15:58 #350845 by ketchim

I mention him earlier then removed the post on Milton with guyana police...

Madray and Pydana ....

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

mapoui
Topic Author
Visitor

13 Sep 2017 16:07 #350847 by mapoui

Madray was not a keeper...

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

mapoui
Topic Author
Visitor

13 Sep 2017 16:09 #350848 by mapoui

but Pydanna did get a game or 3 with the west indies at some point. it wasn't all in vain ::LOL:: ::LOL::

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

The Captain
Offline
Platinum Member

13 Sep 2017 16:49 #350855 by The Captain

why you proposing the best players when than is not what our bajan selectors look at

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.228 seconds

Maleah	As expected, ICC rates MCG Boxing Day Test pitch 'Unsatisfactory'.	(29.12.2025, 08:35)(08:35)
Walker	Havent watched one ball of ILT20, Big Bash, BPL or SA20. Just dont have the capacity to take in all the mindless hitting - it's cricket for the sake of cricket at this stage.	(28.12.2025, 14:37)(14:37)
Maleah	‘IMMENSE SADNESS’: Legendary French actress, Hollywood icon and animal rights activist Brigitte Bardot has died at 91.	(28.12.2025, 11:36)(11:36)
Maleah	Magnificent win for Eng congratulations ? boys well done...	(27.12.2025, 04:22)(04:22)
Maleah	Chase would not be playing test cricket in any other team, much less being captain!	(26.12.2025, 13:43)(13:43)
Brooklyn	Being a West Indies fan means loving a team that keeps testing your heart.	(22.12.2025, 12:44)(12:44)
Brooklyn	What exactly is Roston Chase contributing to the test team?	(19.12.2025, 07:42)(07:42)
Brooklyn	INJURY UPDATE: ? Tagenarine Chanderpaul has been ruled out of the second test between the West Indies and New Zealand due to a side strain. Chanderpaul suffered the injury while playing a shot in the nets on Tuesday. The left handed batter is currently being examined by the medical team to determine the full extent of the injury as well as his availability for the remainder of the series.	(09.12.2025, 19:01)(19:01)
Brooklyn	"Defence becomes an all-encompassing routine: eyes on ball, move your feet, keep head still, pat it down, repeat. No matter whether you need one run to win, or a couple hundred, you defend the same"	(08.12.2025, 16:26)(16:26)
London	So if chase fails again then what? ?	(08.12.2025, 14:23)(14:23)
Julie	England cricket icon Robin Smith has passed away at the age of 62.	(03.12.2025, 20:30)(20:30)
Julie	Former Jets and Commanders WR Laveranues Coles completed nine months of training at the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office Academy and will officially become an officer after his probationary period ?	(02.12.2025, 14:36)(14:36)
Julie	Heartbreaking to hear of the passing of former England cricketer Robin Smith ? Our thoughts are with his friends and family at this difficult time ? Rest in peace, Judge ?	(02.12.2025, 12:56)(12:56)
Julie	JUST IN: Andre Russell calls time on his IPL career and will join KKR’s support staff for 2026 ‼️	(30.11.2025, 14:06)(14:06)
Travis	Shoppers spend billions on Black Friday to snag holiday deals, despite wider economic uncertainty	(29.11.2025, 17:11)(17:11)
Travis	Snow, rain and cold in store for some Thanksgiving travelers	(29.11.2025, 17:10)(17:10)
Travis	The pitch at Perth Stadium was rated "very good" despite a two-day finish in the first Ashes Test	(29.11.2025, 10:57)(10:57)
Travis	We are two days out or so from the start of the New Zealand vs West Indies test series.	(29.11.2025, 10:51)(10:51)
Travis	Pat Cummins did look brilliant in the nets over in Perth but will only be readier for his return come the 3rd Test in Adelaide, which should work perfectly for Australia, especially now that they’re 1-0 up going to the Gabba	(29.11.2025, 10:41)(10:41)
Julie	Sad news: Thirty minutes ago in Dallas, the family of former Dallas Cowboys icon Drew Pearson, aged 73, unexpectedly announced that he has passed away	(29.11.2025, 08:00)(08:00)
Travis	Pat Cummins is set to be included in Australia’s squad for the upcoming second Ashes Test against England in Brisbane, according to reports.	(28.11.2025, 15:19)(15:19)
Travis	Suspect in shooting of National Guard members now facing a first-degree murder charge	(28.11.2025, 14:24)(14:24)
Travis	Lake effect snow piles up in Great Lakes region, impacting Thanksgiving travel	(28.11.2025, 08:50)(08:50)
Travis	Chiefs vs. Cowboys preview Week 13 Perhaps the most perplexing aspect of AT&T Stadium, otherwise known as “Jerry World,” is the glare from the sun that bursts through the windows and shines directly onto the field. Time and time again the glare has impacted players’ visibility during games, yet Jerry Jones refuses to make any changes to account for the sun. Rather than install curtains, Jones has previously said he feels it’s a home-field advantage to have that type of stadium factor impacting games. Well, the glare ended up benefitting the Chiefs early into Thursday’s Thanksgiving game, as a pass from Dak Prescott to George Pickens fell incomplete, at least in part due to the impact of the sun’s glare.	(27.11.2025, 21:18)(21:18)
Travis	AT&T Stadium Glare Led to Plenty of Comments From NFL Fans During Chiefs-Cowboys	(27.11.2025, 21:17)(21:17)
Travis	Kittitian allrounder Kunal Tilokani earns U19 call upKittitian allrounder Kunal Tilokani earns U19 call up	(27.11.2025, 13:19)(13:19)
Travis	'Wanted them to really grovel' - SA coach Shukri Conrad on keeping India on the field	(25.11.2025, 18:29)(18:29)
Julie	Hi	(25.11.2025, 08:45)(08:45)
Julie	motie 130 notout guyana 250	(25.11.2025, 08:44)(08:44)
Matthew	hi	(25.11.2025, 07:00)(07:00)
Julie	19 wickets fall between Aus and Eng and it’s great cricket, 19 wickets fall between W.I and any other country and we should be relegated…the double standards in world cricket.	(21.11.2025, 06:40)(06:40)
Travis	ketchim?	(12.11.2025, 17:40)(17:40)
Travis	kwami?	(12.11.2025, 17:40)(17:40)
Travis	who is this	(12.11.2025, 17:39)(17:39)
Alvin	Chairmsn, I cant Log in	(11.11.2025, 17:16)(17:16)
Serena	This batting performance by the West Indies in the second innings blew me away. I kept closing my eyes and then rubbing and opening them again and sat transfixed as I watch that unbelievable partnership between John Campbell and Shai Hope. What a magnificent performance by these two! It just goes to show that patience, determination and effort can go a long way to improve the performances of the West Indies team. Let us hope that this effort by West Indies batsmen would not be a one-off performance, but will be the beginning of a renewed effort to improve the performances of the team, going forward.	(13.10.2025, 09:28)(09:28)
Serena	John Campbell breaks a 23-year drought for West Indies openers with a Test hundred in India! #INDvsWI #INDvWI #JohnCampbell	(13.10.2025, 05:49)(05:49)
Serena	Let's celebrate that Ind will have to bat again as a notable achievement	(13.10.2025, 05:32)(05:32)
Serena	Defeat in Ahmedabad, we move to Delhi with an aim to the level the series. #INDvWI \| #MenInMaroon	(04.10.2025, 10:38)(10:38)
Serena	? USA Cricket Files for Bankruptcy The Chapter 11 filing makes it the first known ICC member to declare bankruptcy. ⚡?	(03.10.2025, 12:22)(12:22)
Serena	A maiden test wicket for Khary Pierre ends a challenging day 2️⃣ #INDvWI	(03.10.2025, 12:15)(12:15)
Serena	Why is WI best batter batting at #6 and why is he even keeping wickets in test?	(03.10.2025, 07:26)(07:26)
Serena	Give warrican vice captain on wat basis the man does nothing not even help chase	(03.10.2025, 07:10)(07:10)
Serena	WI waiting for declaration. India most likely will declare if or when both Jurel and Jadeja get to their 100s.	(03.10.2025, 05:35)(05:35)
Kade	162 all out : India 121-2 stumps, day1	(02.10.2025, 16:00)(16:00)
Serena	if marriage certificate could get expire like driver's licence a lot of married men will never renew it	(27.09.2025, 10:54)(10:54)
Warren	Jameis Winston is asked about being named QB3 on the Giants' roster behind Russell Wilson and Jaxson Dart: "As a competitor, you want to be the starter. But I prepare to be the starter, I know I'm a starter in this league. But you have to be able to be grateful for your role...my role right now is to assist Russ and Jaxson to be the best that they can be while preparing to be the best that I can be. No matter if I'm 3, 33, this is my first year being number 19, so it's always a first for everything. I focus on what I would love. And what I would love is for this team to have success."	(13.09.2025, 10:58)(10:58)
Monica	e	(11.09.2025, 17:03)(17:03)
Ryland	Lol... Hetmyer. Fell agonizingly short of his century! Just 91 more he needed!	(08.09.2025, 05:53)(05:53)
Ryland	The progress of the PPP government should not be judged by the dissenting voices of a few, but by the tangible benefits it has brought to everyone.	(02.09.2025, 17:51)(17:51)

Pyper

Go to top