>

Ian Bell: Time for a change

More
19 Jul 2015 14:40 #264374 by dillinger10
Although Buttler has had a lean two games to start the series, he is still averaging 40.92 in his 10 Test matches to date with a very healthy strikerate (61.43). He has been one of England's bright spots with the bat and his keeping is improving. There is room for both Bairstow and Buttler in the same team. Both are good outfielders too. I'd replace Bell with Bairstow and rotate the gloves between Bairstow and Buttler to keep them both fresh.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
19 Jul 2015 14:44 #264376 by ketchim
no excuses ! Selectors shouldda pay attention to Jonny warm up numbers .

BUT they chose to go on historical stats to play it safe.

I say that Bairstow would have come closer to that 566 in partnership with Stokes and Moeen.

And in the 2nd innings neither Stokes or Moeen would have returned DUCKS !!

But I may be biased to the red head    ::LOL::

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
19 Jul 2015 15:11 #264377 by dillinger10
Bell, Lyth and Ballance are all in danger of losing their places in the team before Buttler. Bell's best days are behind him and whether it is during this series, after this series or at the end of the year, his run in the side is likely over.

England are in desperate need of finding an opening partner for Cook. It has been a revolving door of new (and old faces in Trott) since Strauss retired and no one player has stepped up to make the position their own. Lyth has struggled so far with an average of 25 in 4 Tests. Seven of his eight dismissals so far have been caught behind the stumps, either by the wicket-keeper or in the slip cordon. Yet only one of these would have gone on to hit the stumps. The ability to leave the wide balls alone in Test match cricket, especially as an opener when facing the new ball, is paramount to success. Lyth likes to feel bat on ball and continually plays at balls outside his off stump. By contrast, Cook, when at his best, is quite content to leave anything outside off alone and force the bowlers to bring the ball into his pads, a strong area where he scores at will.

Ballance's technique is also coming under serious fire. He stays so deep in the crease and is susceptible to anything full and straight. He got off to a fantastic start to his Test career but his footwork has been exposed by both the New Zealand quicks and now the Australians. Whether he can make the adjustment remains to be seen. Of the three, he is the most likely to remain in the side.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
19 Jul 2015 17:29 #264399 by TRINIDADDY
I would try Eoin Morgan in tests, though his domestic test average is poor.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • bala24
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
21 Jul 2015 12:06 #264579 by bala24
He can play at 5 or 6.
but as stated he should be used as an advantage with his spin,don't england have a real spinner at all ??
The batting can have a bit of reshuffling,maybe getting bairstow at 4 too.
Morgan at 3 down too would be a great choice.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Jul 2015 12:26 #264588 by ketchim
Ian said he misses Kevin ...  :-[

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Jul 2015 13:04 #264611 by dillinger10
Morgan at 3 would be horrific. He has never batted higher than 6 for England and bats 4 for Middlesex but has been shockingly out of form this year.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Jul 2015 13:07 #264615 by dillinger10

Morgan is such a curious case. He is unbelievably talented and one of my favourite cricketers to watch when he is on. He was given a brief run in the Test side and failed to live up to expectations (16 matches at an average of 30). He had a good county season last year averaging 45, but has been incredibly underwhelming so far this year - 61 runs in 4 matches at an average of 10.17.

For me, all roads lead back to one man: Johnny Bairstow. Bairstow has played 7 county championship matches so far this year with an average of 100.66. He has scored 5 centuries (including another over the weekend), 3 fifties and a high score of 219*. I am not sure what more he can do to force his way into the team. He has been batting 5 for Yorkshire this year, so if he did replace Bell, I'd imagine England would look to move Root up the order.

If not Bairstow, other candidates include Alex Hales, James Taylor, James Vince and Daniel Bell-Drummond. Throwing youngsters like Vince and Bell-Drummond into the fire of an Ashes series is less than ideal, and Taylor, despite a century at the weekend, has been woefully short of runs.

If Lyth doesn't pan out, the most likely candidate to replace him would be Alex Hales. I like that he is right-handed as I believe there is an advantage of having a R/L combination at the top of the order. He is aggressive and in good form for Notts, averaging 46.2 in 8 matches.

Other candidates to replace Lyth would be a mixture of old retreads (Carberry and Compton) and new unknowns (Lees). Lees is still young and raw, and hasn't replicated last seasons form. Carberry is 34 and averaging just 33.47 for Hampshire this year. That leaves Nick Compton who is in form (averaging 40 for Middlesex) although at age 32 and having already been discarded by England once, I can't see them turning back to him again.

In reality, Lyth, at a minimum, will get the rest of this series to prove himself and most likely the tour of Pakistan too.

One thing that is certain, England's top order has been disastrous in 2015. In 11 of 13 Test innings this year, England have bettered 74/3 on only two occasions. In the four innings against Australia so far this series, the first 3 wickets have fallen for 43, 73, 29 and 42. That is not a recipe for success, especially against a potent attack like Australia.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
27 Jul 2015 02:04 #265279 by dillinger10
This ESPN article makes for grim reading if you are an England fan. It further expands upon the numbers I provided earlier in this thread, and sadly, they just re-iterate the fact that Bell has no place in this team. Since 2012, in 42 Tests, Bell averages 34.69 when batting in the top six; among top-order batsman, only Shane Watson has a lower average.

www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/902675.html

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
27 Jul 2015 12:13 #265337 by Rowe992
Well I think Bell is also finished as an English international player. His days are numbered and he should just retire as the likes of Strauss did.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.221 seconds
PeytonCOACH SAMMY TO MISS IRELAND T20Is(05.06.2025, 18:49)(18:49)0
ketchimJune 1st 2ndODI : replace the 4 guys on the bench : Evin Lewis, John Campbell, Shamar Joseph and Jediah Blades !(31.05.2025, 15:09)(15:09)0
chairmanHuge defeat(29.05.2025, 19:07)(19:07)0
chairmanMatthew Forde you beauty. I didn't even realise he averages almost 40 in FC. And he is only 23 yrs old.(23.05.2025, 20:05)(20:05)0
chairmanWelcome to Guyana - Hakeem Olajuwon, also known as "The Dream,"
A storied career:

- 2x NBA Champion (1994, 1995)
- 2x NBA Finals MVP (1994, 1995)
- 12x NBA All-Star
- 12x All-NBA Team selection
- 9x NBA All-Defensive First Team
- NBA MVP (1994)
- NBA Defensive Player of the Year (1994)
- NBA Rookie of the Year (1984)
- Inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 2008

One of the greatest players in NBA history.
(23.05.2025, 10:05)(10:05)0
chairmanI would like to see every house in Essequibo has a Guyana ?? Flag
and possibly the Rest of Guyana ??
(19.05.2025, 06:38)(06:38)0
PeytonSevere weather leaves at least 27 dead, including 18 in Kentucky(17.05.2025, 18:46)(18:46)0
chairmanCongratulations to the newly appointed Roston Chase as West Indies Test captain.
Does he have any captain/ leadership experience?
Your thoughts:
(16.05.2025, 19:23)(19:23)0
TalonDozens of white South Africans arrive in US under Trump refugee plan(12.05.2025, 19:57)(19:57)0
BryantRomario Shepherd hits the FATEST FIFTY for any batter in RCB colours!
Second fastest fifty in the history of the IPL.
(03.05.2025, 15:16)(15:16)0
JamisonTrump celebrates the Super Bowl champ Eagles at White House(30.04.2025, 18:26)(18:26)0
JamisonUNC’s Belichick defends Hudson as ‘doing her job’ after interjecting during CBS interview(30.04.2025, 18:25)(18:25)0
JamisonHundreds of scholars say U.S. is swiftly heading toward authoritarianism(22.04.2025, 18:58)(18:58)0
JamisonGunmen break into former Seahawks player Richard Sherman's home with family inside(01.04.2025, 18:34)(18:34)0
JamisonRichard Chamberlain, the handsome hero of the 1960s television series “Dr. Kildare” who found a second career as an award-winning “king of the miniseries,” has died. He was 90.(30.03.2025, 10:58)(10:58)0
BridgerWest Indies cricket team official website(23.03.2025, 00:23)(00:23)0
LyricUnfortunately, after spending 9 months in space, looking over the entire earth, the two Astronauts failed to locate APNU/AFC SOPs.(18.03.2025, 22:04)(22:04)0
LyricThe hour we lost was the one when I was planning to go to the gym(11.03.2025, 17:59)(17:59)0
GianniWest Indies latest Test match scorecard(11.03.2025, 11:34)(11:34)0
ScarletSteven Smith South Africa cricket(10.03.2025, 12:11)(12:11)0
ketchimCanada get new Prime Minister : Edmonton Mark Carney !(09.03.2025, 20:51)(20:51)0
ConnerDr. Ashni Singh quote on government's stance on corrupt practices(08.03.2025, 16:12)(16:12)0
LyricGuy scored 368 bowl out Jam for 44 & didn't enforce the follow-on? That's bull crap(07.03.2025, 09:37)(09:37)0
LyricYesterday, my wife thought she saw a cockroach in the kitchen. She sprayed everything down and cleaned thoroughly.
Today I'm putting the cockroach in the bathroom.
(06.03.2025, 17:19)(17:19)0
ShilohU.S. says consequences for Maduro regime if provocation continues(02.03.2025, 08:56)(08:56)0
Shiloh–Guyana stands firmly against Venezuela’s incursion(02.03.2025, 08:56)(08:56)0
PatienceCongratulations to Trinidadian, Jason Mohammed on an outstanding achievement—three consecutive first class centuries!
• 176 against CCC
• 103 against Windward Islands
• An unbeaten 204 against Leeward Islands
(15.02.2025, 21:22)(21:22)0
NovaGPHC fires senior doctor, suspends two others after investigation of stillbirth(14.02.2025, 19:40)(19:40)0
Amareinfluential women in West Indies cricket(09.02.2025, 03:16)(03:16)0
PatienceSteven Smith scored yet another test century (36) and belongs to the list of one-off the greatest batsmen in the history of cricket!(08.02.2025, 20:51)(20:51)0
PatienceBEAUTIFUL GUYANA CRUSH TINY BARBADOS HANDSOMELY INSIDE THREE DAYS AT GUYANA NATIONAL LORDS STADIUM .(01.02.2025, 12:35)(12:35)0
MarissaSteve Smith scored yet another test century today!
The greatest batsman in the world today!
(30.01.2025, 13:21)(13:21)0
MarissaTHE GENUINE WEST INDIES FANS REALLY DID ENJOY AND APPRECIATE THIS VICTORY.(27.01.2025, 07:40)(07:40)0
MarissaAn excellent fight back by the West Indies to dismiss Pakistan for 154. Warrican 4/43 and Motie 3/49. Well done lads. Let the cricket play.(25.01.2025, 11:44)(11:44)0
LanceTrump says he’s considering ‘getting rid of FEMA’ as he visits hurricane-damaged North Carolina(24.01.2025, 19:55)(19:55)0
DeaconCumberbatch(22.01.2025, 12:19)(12:19)0
Marissa$135 fuh reporting yuh mattie to ICE,deez nex few monts going to be quite interesting(22.01.2025, 07:51)(07:51)0
AndersExxonMobil write-down natural gas fields(21.01.2025, 00:42)(00:42)0
MarissaJangoo should be in next game , captain should be dropped,Kacy karty, should be dropped,if roach is fit I would bring him in at the expense of st Clair.(20.01.2025, 17:41)(17:41)0
Baileymessage(20.01.2025, 15:25)(15:25)0
MercyKensington Oval stadium ticket policy(20.01.2025, 00:36)(00:36)0
LanceKraigg’s time is up. He has never truly moved on as a player. Despite being captain and senior batsmen we will lose nothing with investing in a rookie.

He has given his service as an honest and wholehearted performer and would leave with my heartfelt thanks for his contribution.
(18.01.2025, 19:00)(19:00)0
ByronViv richards was the best batsman of
“his era” but he wasn’t better than Brian Lara whether it’s numbers wise or just plain batting talent and skill
Lara is on a level nobody else is on.
(17.01.2025, 18:56)(18:56)0
ByronAmir jangoo replace dasilva(17.01.2025, 07:56)(07:56)0
ByronTevin imlach gets debut(17.01.2025, 07:56)(07:56)0
LindaMy question about the West Indies cricket team.(13.01.2025, 10:06)(10:06)0
ByronWhy doesn't England have big cricket stadiums like those in Australia and India..?(11.01.2025, 16:31)(16:31)0
MaliyahHow do I purchase tickets for the upcoming cricket match at Kensington Oval in Barbados?(11.01.2025, 16:27)(16:27)0
ArielWest Indies vs India T20 match(11.01.2025, 15:59)(15:59)0
LanceFORMER JAMAICA and West Indies left-arm spinner Nikita Miller is excited about imparting his knowledge of the game to the Caribbean side’s spin-bowling unit for the upcoming two-Test series against Pakistan.(10.01.2025, 19:11)(19:11)0
Zara
Go to top